HOA Fees Too High? How to Reduce or Dispute Them

The average monthly HOA fee nationwide has risen significantly. According to a recent analysis, nearly one-third of homeowners across the largest metro areas are subject to HOA or condo fees. Of those, more than 15% are paying over $500 a month — an extra $6,000-plus per year on top of the mortgage.[1]

You can't simply stop paying HOA fees. But depending on your situation, you may have more options than you think. You might be able to dispute a fine, challenge a special assessment, negotiate a payment plan, or push back on a fee increase. In rare cases, you may be able to reduce your dues by getting more involved in how your HOA is run.

This guide covers what each type of HOA fee is, what happens if you don't pay, and the concrete steps you can take to dispute or reduce what you owe.

The three types of HOA fees

Before exploring your options, it helps to understand what kind of fee you're dealing with. Your rights and leverage differ significantly depending on the fee type.

	Regular dues	Special assessments	Fines
How often	Monthly or quarterly	One-time, as needed	When a rule is violated
Mandatory?	Almost always	Usually, with some exceptions	Yes, but easier to dispute
Can you dispute?	Rarely	Sometimes, depending on state law	Yes - most viable option
Non-payment consequences	Lien, collections, foreclosure (in some states)	Same as regular dues	Lien if unpaid long enough
Best strategy	Negotiate a payment plan if behind; push back on increases through member vote	Challenge non-urgent assessments; verify state approval requirements	Appeal to the board; document your case

Regular dues

Regular dues are the mandatory fees you pay on a set schedule (usually monthly) to remain a member of your HOA. They cover fixed, ongoing expenses: insurance, landscaping, maintenance, vendor contracts, and contributions to the reserve fund.

These are the hardest fees to avoid. As long as you're a member of a mandatory HOA, you're obligated to pay them. You can easily leave a voluntary HOA to stop paying fees, but opting out of a mandatory HOA entirely is rarely possible.

Special assessments

When a large or unexpected expense arises that regular dues can't cover, your HOA may issue a special assessment: a one-time fee charged to all members.

Special assessments are also mandatory in most cases. However, you often have more grounds to dispute them than regular dues, particularly when the assessment is for a non-urgent project.

• California: A board cannot impose a special assessment that exceeds 5% of the annual budgeted expenses without the approval of a majority of members.[2]
• Texas: A board is prohibited from voting on a special assessment behind closed doors or via email. It must be done in an open meeting with at least 6 days' notice to homeowners, giving you the chance to speak up before the vote.[3]
• Illinois: This state offers a unique veto right. If your total fees jump by more than 15% year-over-year (special assessment included), owners have 14 days to petition for a meeting. If a majority of the total membership votes to reject it, the assessment is blocked.[4]

One important recent development: following the 2021 Surfside condominium collapse in Florida, several states have passed laws requiring HOAs and condo associations to conduct reserve studies and fund reserves adequately. This has led to significant special assessment increases in some communities, particularly older condo buildings.

For example, Florida’s 2022 legislation and subsequent laws now mandate milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies for buildings three stories or higher.[5] They also prohibit associations from voting to waive or underfund reserves for these repairs. For homeowners in these buildings, this shift has triggered mandatory special assessments to catch up on years of deferred maintenance, leaving them with almost no room for negotiation.

Fines

Fines are issued for violations of your HOA's Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), bylaws, or rules. Common reasons include parking violations, landscaping issues, exterior modifications, noise complaints, and prohibited pets.

Fines are the most disputable of the three fee types. Your HOA is required to follow a due process before a fine becomes enforceable, which typically includes a written notice of the violation and an opportunity to be heard.

State laws dictate exactly what this process looks like. In Florida, your association must give you at least 14 days’ written notice of the right to a hearing before a fine is imposed. The hearing must be held before an independent and impartial committee of at least three members. California, meanwhile, requires at least 10 days’ notice before a hearing. The notice must include the meeting details, the nature of the violation, and a statement of the member’s rights.[6]

How to reduce or dispute HOA fees

How to dispute a fine

Fines are your most realistic target if you're looking to reduce what you owe. Here's how to approach it.

Step 1: Review the alleged violation. Pull out your CC&Rs and confirm the rule you allegedly violated actually exists and was violated. Check whether the fine amount is within the limits set by your CC&Rs or state law.

Step 2: Check whether proper notice was given. Most states require the HOA to provide written notice of the violation and a reasonable opportunity to cure it before issuing a fine. If that process wasn't followed, you have procedural grounds to dispute.

Step 3: Document your case. Gather evidence: photos, correspondence, records of prior board approval, or documentation showing the condition has existed for years without enforcement. Your case is stronger if:

• You have already corrected the issue
• A previous board gave you verbal or written permission
• The same violation is widespread in the community without enforcement
• The "violation" is protected by state or federal law (for example, a wheelchair ramp required under the ADA)
• You can show that the rule was selectively enforced against you

Step 4: Submit a written appeal. Write a brief, factual letter to the board requesting a hearing. Stick to the facts, and avoid emotional language. Keep a copy.

Senior lawyer at MK Law, Marcus Denning, notes that the most effective appeals are those that force the board to prove they did their own homework. “When a homeowner skips past all of that and writes in saying the fine is unjust, then they give the board an easy dismissal,” says Denning. “But when they go back through these steps and ask the board to provide written affirmation that each one of the steps was followed, boards get uncomfortable fast because the paper trail usually has gaps.”

Here’s what an example of an appeal may look like:

Step 5: Attend the hearing. Most HOAs are required to offer a formal hearing before a fine becomes final. Present your case calmly. Bring documentation.

Step 6: Escalate if necessary. If the board upholds the fine and you believe it's wrongful, you can:

• File a complaint with your state's HOA oversight agency
• Request mediation, which is required before litigation in some states
• Consult an HOA attorney about whether legal action is warranted

Is it worth fighting? Steven Wallace, managing attorney at Wallace Law, warns that unless the HOA fundamentally lacks the right to fine you or you were already in compliance, the financial math rarely adds up. “Attorney fees incurred by the HOA often greatly outweigh the fine itself,” says Wallace. Before jumping in, consider that if you lose the dispute, you could end up responsible for the HOA’s legal bills on top of your own.

How to challenge a special assessment

Special assessments are harder to fight than fines but easier than regular dues. Your best grounds for a challenge:

• The assessment exceeds the threshold requiring a member vote. Several states require member approval for large assessments. In California, any special assessment exceeding 5% of the gross annual budget requires a membership vote. Similarly, Maryland boards must call a special meeting if a proposed assessment for a capital improvement exceeds 15% of the annual budget.[7]
• The project isn't urgent. Emergency health and safety repairs typically don't require member approval. Non-urgent improvements usually do. In Florida, while boards have broad authority to fund necessary maintenance, they are generally prohibited from bypassing owners’ votes for optional upgrades or aesthetic changes.[8]
• The assessment wasn't properly noticed. Most states require advance written notice. Check your CC&Rs and state law for the required timeline. For example, in Texas, the board must provide notice about any assessment-related meeting 10–60 days prior.[9]
• The amount is disproportionate or the funds were mismanaged. If you believe the assessment reflects financial mismanagement, you may have grounds to demand a financial accounting.

How to refuse a fee increase

HOA fees increase over time (typically annually) to keep up with inflation and rising operating costs. You can't refuse to pay an increase outright, but you can contest it.

Here are your options:

• Vote against the budget. In most states, HOA members have the right to vote on the annual budget, including fee increases. Organize your neighbors and vote it down.
• Check your CC&Rs for a cap. Many CC&Rs limit how much fees can increase annually. Review yours before assuming an increase is valid.
• Check state law. Some states cap HOA fee increases by percentage. For example, in Arizona and California, regular assessment increases are limited to 20% per year, and any higher amount requires a majority vote of membership.[11][12]

Note: HOA boards have a financial incentive to keep delinquency rates low to preserve members' ability to get FHA and conventional financing. If fees are pricing members out, that's a concrete argument you can make to the board — not just an appeal to fairness.

How to reduce your HOA fees long-term

If you can't eliminate fees, the most sustainable strategy is to influence how they're set. As an HOA member, you have more power than most people use.

Get involved in the budget process. HOA members typically have the right to review the annual budget and vote on it. Attend budget meetings, ask questions about line items, and organize neighbors who share your concerns.

While a third of homeowners feel their fees are too high, nearly the same amount (32%) never actually cast a vote on community issues.[13] With only 41% of residents showing up to meetings, the loudest voices often end up making the rules. Showing up to vote is your best tool for fighting rules and fees you don’t support.

Run for the board. Board membership gives you direct influence over vendor contracts, service decisions, and the reserve fund strategy — the biggest drivers of fee levels.

Propose specific cost reductions. Come to board meetings with concrete proposals: renegotiating a vendor contract, reducing a service you can show members don't use, or adjusting the reserve fund contribution schedule. Vague complaints rarely move boards; specific, documented proposals sometimes do. 

What happens if you don't pay HOA fees?

Not paying your HOA fees is rarely a viable strategy. The consequences escalate quickly:

1. Late fees and interest. Most HOAs charge penalties for missed payments, specified in the CC&Rs
2. Loss of privileges. Access to shared amenities (pool, gym, parking) may be suspended
3. Collections referral. The account may be sent to a collections agency, damaging your credit
4. Rental income seizure. If you rent your home, some HOAs can intercept rent payments
5. Lien on your property. The HOA can record a lien, blocking you from selling or refinancing until the debt is resolved
6. Lawsuit. The HOA can sue you and, if successful, hold you responsible for their attorney fees
7. Foreclosure. In some states, an HOA can foreclose on your property for unpaid dues

HOA foreclosure rights vary significantly by state. While most states still permit it, several have restricted or eliminated it in recent years. For example, California restricts foreclosures until the debt exceeds a certain threshold (currently $1,800) or a twelve-month time limit.[14] In Colorado, an HOA can no longer foreclose on you just for unpaid or late fees — though they can pursue foreclosure for regular dues.[15]

“I have seen HOAs that foreclose when one payment is past due,” warns Wallace. “Often, the attorney fees are triple what the fine was.” Because most HOAs have fee-shifting clauses, once your file hits a lawyer’s desk, you’re on the hook for their hourly rates.

To avoid this fee-shifting trap, the best move is to contact your board the moment you realize you’re falling behind. Most associations are willing to negotiate a payment plan or waive late fees if you reach out before they hand your file to a collection attorney.

Pro tip: When you reach out, suggest a specific amount you can pay immediately. Boards are more likely to say yes to “I can pay $100 today and the rest over four months” than “I’m too broke right now.” This shows you’re acting in good faith.

If you fall behind, negotiate a payment plan

If you're struggling to keep up with dues, your best first step is to contact your HOA board directly and request a payment plan before penalties escalate.

In some states, such as Colorado, HOAs are legally required to offer a repayment plan in good faith before resorting to more drastic collection efforts.[17] Similarly, Texas law mandates that associations with more than 14 lots must provide an alternative payment schedule.[18] In California, while a board isn’t forced to grant every request, they are required to meet with you to discuss a proposed plan if you ask for one.[19]

“Boards are generally receptive to payment plans of up to a year with at least 15-20% down payment,” shares Wallace.

Here's how to request a payment plan:

1. Keep copies of all correspondence.
2. Contact the board or property management company in writing, not just by phone.
3. Acknowledge the debt and explain your circumstances briefly and professionally.
4. Propose specific terms: a monthly repayment amount and a timeline.
5. Ask for the agreement in writing once terms are accepted.

Bankruptcy and HOA fees

Declaring bankruptcy to escape HOA fees is an extreme step that's not recommended unless you're already considering bankruptcy for broader financial reasons. If you are in that situation, here's how HOA fees are treated:

Chapter 7 bankruptcy: Pre-petition HOA fees (owed before you file) may be discharged. However, fees that accrue after you file are not discharged.[20] You remain responsible for them as long as you own the property. You are also more likely to lose your home in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Chapter 13 bankruptcy: Pre-petition HOA fees are reorganized into a repayment plan rather than discharged. You keep your home, but the debt doesn't disappear.[21]

Related reading